Has anyone ever had a bad midwife experience?
ByWith my first son I used a midwife and really enjoyed it. My sister n law used the same midwife and had a horrible experience.
Has anyone else had a bad experience?
She was in labor at the Birth Center for 2 days before they took her to the hospital for a c – section.
Related posts:


11 Comments
April 18th, 2010 at 11:34 am
Why did she have a horrible experience? In the UK we only get midwifes, so we have to put up with them if they’re bad or not, i personally love my midwife, she’s well knowledged and is very attentive to my needs.
April 18th, 2010 at 11:49 am
i didnt…why did ur sister?
April 18th, 2010 at 12:23 pm
I had a midwife with my first and loved it we had a great experience….with my second i used a regular doctor and missed the relationship..i felt like i was just another patient to her..so with this pregnancy i went back to a midwife…and i wish i would of just kept my doctor…shes a good doctor and very nice i just feel like she doesnt really help or awnser my questions right…shes very “all natural” so its hard to ask questions about getting my tubes tied after and things like that…but its okay this is my last baby and im due in a week so hopefully the birthing experience will be nice and quick
April 18th, 2010 at 1:15 pm
I’ve NEVER heard of a bad midwife experience.
What was so horrible about your sisters experience? Sometimes people have a certain idea of how things “should” be but don’t talk with there midwife about it and then somehow seem disappointed. The key to a good midwife experience is choosing the right midwife for you.
April 18th, 2010 at 1:40 pm
ive never used one personally i just dont trust them id must rather have a dr who is fully prepared for anything that could happen a midwife isnt i just dont want to put my childs life in the hands of someone who isnt fully experienced with everything..
April 18th, 2010 at 2:07 pm
my first pregnancy was with a midwife, she was horrible. not knowledgable at all.
second time..awesome. loved her!
third time, I couldn’t have asked for a better person. she joked with me the whole time.
I’m sorry your she had a bad experience. 2 days!? hmm that sounds..excruiciating.
April 18th, 2010 at 2:20 pm
I have heard of some, but I haven’t had one.
One midwife in particular in our area (I’m in the US by the way) runs a very busy birth center. She has lots of clients, so less time to offer comfort measures. She gave a friend’s baby a bottle instead of supplementing with a cup feeder. She doesn’t inform mom of what’s going on the way one would expect from a midwife. She uses techniques that render the mom a passive participant in birth rather than an active one. In general, she’s just sort of gruff.
I haven’t met her but I have been told I don’t want to. My midwives are great though. There are two already-licensed midwives and then an apprentice (who is actually a friend of mine and is doing all of my prenatal care and the delivery, supervised by one of the others). I feel confident we’ll have a great birth with their help
Edit: Looking at the details, it does seem that the experience was horrible, but it’s possible that the midwife did the best she could. A midwife’s job is to facilitate a natural, healthy labor, and also to evaluate when and if it is necessary to transfer care to the hospital. A c-section may have been necessary for any number of reasons beyond the midwife’s control. I do think she should’ve gone with her to the hospital if possible, just for moral support and to help with breastfeeding and bonding after the birth.
April 18th, 2010 at 3:04 pm
I love my midwife to death. But having to have a c-section is not your midwife’s fault. That’s just how your friend’s labor panned out.
To the person who said that midwives aren’t experienced or prepared- you’re wrong. Midwives have been caring for women in labor since there have been humans. Doctors only truly came on the scene at the beginning of the 20th century. And I would really challeng their ‘experience.’ They know only a couple of tricks to solve a problem and then they want to cut the baby out. Midwives are much more versed in the process of labor and childbirth.
April 18th, 2010 at 3:32 pm
my midwife was crap basically. id go 3 months until i got an appointment sometimes, even then id be lucky if she turned up. she forgot who i was and always thought i was having a boy. when i was diagnosed with pre-eclampsia she let me go a week overdue until she agreed to send me in for induction which was too late by then i went into labour naturally. she was useless and id never go back there when i have my next baby.
April 18th, 2010 at 4:27 pm
I visited a midwife for my prenatal visits with my first child. My experience was horrible! I had an eating disorder for 5 years prior to my pregnancy that I had been struggling with, I was doing counseling etc, and I would stop and pick it back up… Anyway when I became pregnant 5 months prior to my daughters conception I had a misscarriage due to my health even though I had started eating normally and was devistated , so when I got pregnant with my daughter I was really focused on eating right and I started packing on weight extremely fast! I gained 70 lbs with that pregnancy. But I was worth it for the health of my child… The midwife I had was constantly making comments like ” do you eat mcdonalds every day or what, why are you gaining so much weight” and “i lost over 100lbs recently, if you ate right like me you’d gain weight slower” even though she had my medical record and knew about my condition. And I kept trying to schedule with some one else and kept getting stuck with her! She made me feel horrible about myself at a time when I had made a tremendous change in my life. Even if I was gaining weight like that because I was eating crazy (which I wasn’t my body was just messed up because of my mistakes) she shouldn’t have treated me like that. And she acted like my questions were stupid. I was 20 at the time so I didn’t know about some things, but come on LOL they’re supposed to be supportive! Luckily I got a nice doctor for my delivery instead of my midwife or I would have lost my mind!
April 18th, 2010 at 5:25 pm
I had a horrible experience with a midwife when i went into hospital with severe bleeding resulting in premature labour.
The midwife kept pressuring me to tell her what i had taken and told me that the reason i was bleeding and going into premature labour was because of the drugs i had taken which i could understand if i took any drugs i never have in my life i explained this and she just mumbled somethin about it being my baby i was damaging.
I later found out from a student midwife that there had been a mistake and that a part of someone else’s notes were put in with mine , no aplogies or anything and i didnt see the first midwife again.
As if i wasnt going through enough as it was