Having a home birth & midwife/doula vs. hospital?
ByI’ve always wanted to have my babies in something like a natural birthing center, which there were a bunch of when I lived down in Florida. I now live in Omaha, Nebraska and am finally pregnant… and there are no natural birthing centers here. At all. So I’m considering a home birth with a midwife or a doula but I’m worried of the safety and such…
Has anyone done a home birth with a midwife before and if so were you scared/how did everything turn out?
Related posts:
- can i have a natural labor in the hospital with a midwife and my wishes?
- Might not be able to get a midwife. Cannot conceive of delivering in hospital as being a good thing. Help?
- Anyone birth with midwife in hospital?
- Considering a home birth with a midwife. Any tips or info I should know?
- Anyone had a home birth with a midwife?


11 Comments
April 21st, 2010 at 9:33 am
hospital
April 21st, 2010 at 9:57 am
I haven’t done a home birth yet but with this one I am doing a home birth in a birthing pool. I get more attention with a midwife than I did with an OBGYN. I couldn’t call him as much and it made me nervous to call. Instead most of the time I just went to the hospital on my own. This time I have no fear calling her she is great! I had a few worries with my midwife at first but now after talking to her and getting to know her I am totally comfortable going into labor at home and doing it on my own!!! Good luck hope this helped
April 21st, 2010 at 10:36 am
I have not, but I did think about it.
I was in so much pain from my first and I also ended up having a small complication with scar tissue so I was very happy that I did go with a doctor and hospital birth.
When you are pregnant with your first you are so nervous about what will happen and what will it feel like and all of that so you get over worked. I say if you go for it then you should look into hypno-birthing. This is a form of pain management where you focus on what your body is doing and the end result and it relieves the pain for you. You are able to move past the pain and place yourself in a trance like state where you do not acknowledge the pain. This worked wonderfully for my second and third.
I had 3 natural births fyi with no pain meds!
Good Luck!
April 21st, 2010 at 10:42 am
actually more problems tend to arise in hospitals where there are more interventions. i plan to have my next at home. i had my son in a hospita and i hated it. i feel at home i will be comfortable, be able to eat and drink as i please and feel in control. at the hospital you don’t get any of that. you might also have some doctors that push for c-section for no reason. it’s about teh same mortaility rate and if you’re having a healthy pregnancy then it sounds fine
April 21st, 2010 at 10:50 am
I’ve known several people who had home births with midwives and it all went very well. They are safe. Good luck!
April 21st, 2010 at 11:16 am
I strongly suggest delivering in a Hospital!!!! All type of things can go wrong such as breach baby,excessive bleeding, lost of blood, cord wrapped around the babies kneck… It’s safer in a hospital because they can work fast to stabilize the issue at hands where a home birth you have no equipments to help the issue.. the midwife would have to call an ambulance if something goes horribly wrong… There’s a fetal monitor, Drugs!!!! At a hospital
April 21st, 2010 at 11:29 am
If your doctor can 100% guarantee you that you will not have any complications, then have your baby at home or in a birthing center.
However, should a problem arise at home or a birthing center, an ambulance will have to be called and you will have to be driven by ambulance to the ER to then get taken to the Labor and Delivery unit.
It doesn’t matter if the birthing center is across the street from the hospital. You will still have to go by ambulance from the birthing center to the ER to the L&D unit.
FYI-
Most of the emergencies that arise without warning at a low-risk birth — the baby’s shoulders are stuck (shoulder dystocia); the baby doesn’t breathe; heavy bleeding — can be resolved or stabilized for hospital transport by a skilled pair of hands and readily portable medication and equipment.
Read more: http://parenting.ivillage.com/pregnancy/plabor/0,,6rl1,00.html#ixzz0OIbH0VQr
Not trying to scare you, but make sure you check out all options.
April 21st, 2010 at 11:31 am
I have 2 sisters that have had 3 home births between them. They both had great experiences, and in that situation, I think you’re a lot more comfortable, since you are in your own environment and therefore have more control. I would suggest getting a midwife, or doula, just to guide you as far as healthy eating and other simple typical pregnancy worries. All my sisters children turned out healthier, I think, than they would have if they were born at a hospital. Good luck, and congrats!!!
April 21st, 2010 at 12:16 pm
I am planning an unassisted home birth (a VBAC) in water for October.
Birth is more likely to go wrong at a hospital, since you have doctors pushing unnecessary interventions, not “allowing” laboring moms to eat or walk, forcing them to push flat on their backs…etc. It’s terrible that so many moms have to fight for the births they want. My friend as an example was submarined a couple months back; she had specifically stated NO Pitocin on her birth plan, came in doing fine at 5 cm, and the MINUTE the nurse hooked up her IV, she plopped a bag of Pitocin on there!! My poor friend didn’t even consent! It’s disgusting. She was then in so much pain she was shaking and crying (this was her second child, and without the pitocin she was doing totally okay). So she consented to an epidural (her second needless intervention), which was screwed up and only numbed ONE leg, nothing else! Now she was feeling everything and was unable to move. Being confined to the bed made it worse, and they kept making her lie down to push. No surprise 20 some hours later when she ended up having a C-section! Grrrr. I was appalled at that story.
Sorry to rant a bit, but it is just very upsetting to see what birth has become. I will NEVER set foot in a hospital to labor again, unless a serious complication arises.
April 21st, 2010 at 1:07 pm
I am 36 weeks pregnant and having a home birth with a midwife. I had a hospital birth with my son and didnt like the experience.
I would have to DISAGREE with the comments some people have made in regards to a hospital being safer. A midwife is completely capable of everything, including administering an epidural, should you need one. They are registered nurses, before they can even consider being a midwife. They also need to take 3 yrs of schooling, plus internship, with OBGYN doctors, so they end up with an incredible amount of training. The only thing she cant do for you is a C section for obvious reasons.
I find that they are much more focused on their patients, where docs can be so overloaded, that they dont have a half hour to devote to your appointments. Ive also found that you can always have someone to call to ask questions. With docs, tends to be just office hours.
I think that if you are really serious about having a home birth, you should check out exactly what a midwife can offer you, and what a doctor can offer you at a hospital. Take a tour of the local hospital and see what their labour and delivery wing looks like. That way you will be able to make a really well informed decision about what would work best for you.
Hope it helps
April 21st, 2010 at 2:00 pm
I had my first baby at a hospital, and I will never set foot in a hospital maternity ward again, barring a life-threatening emergency. I am pregnany again, and planning a home birth with a CPM (certified professional midwife). We had originally wanted to use a birth center, but it was too expensive and I really wanted a home birth. The center was just a compromise with my husband.
Read everything you can about natural childbirth. Make sure you understand the physiology of birth and know what to expect. Find a midwife you trust, educate yourself, and be prepared to transfer if needed, but do not plan on it. Statistics show that home birth in a low-risk pregnancy is as safe as a hospital for a first time mom, and at least as safe if not safer for a mom who has had a baby before.
Good luck and congratulations on your pregnancy!
ETA: Midwives DO have a fetal monitor, I don’t know why so many people think they don’t. They don’t use constant fetal monitoring, because it is proven to increase the c-section rate and actually causes more problems than it prevents. It was never meant to be used universally the way it is in hospitals today; it was intended for high-risk labors only. Intermittent fetal monitoring is more effective, and allows mom to move around, so it doesn’t slow down labor. Midwives also carry Pitocin to prevent maternal hemorrhage, and can handle any complication that comes up, even if it is stabilizing mom and baby for an ambulance ride to the hospital. Often, a home birth mama can be in the OR getting a stat c-section faster than a woman in the hospital, because the midwife calls the hospital while she is waiting on the ambulance so that they can prep the OR. If you can get to the hospital in less than 20 minutes, you are likely to be in surgery faster than a mom who labored in the hospital.